The primitive man had lived in kinship
with nature. Such was his/her close fellowship with nature that man had even
projected many of his attributes onto the animals/plants.
For instance, poet Kalidasa depicted
deer as the brother and Vanajyotsna, the creeper, as the sister of
Sakuntala in his famous drama, Abhijnanasakuntalam. In the same
play, we hear sage Kanva proclaiming to the sylvan deities and the trees
of the hermitage, “Sakuntala … would not drink till she had wet/Your roots,
a sister’s duty/Nor pluck your flowers; she loves you yet/Far more than
selfish beauty.”
That was the harmony in which the
ancient man lived with nature, believing that in bird and beast, tree and man,
it is the same life: …that impends / all thinking things, all objects of all
thought / and rolls through all things.
But with the advent of civilization,
economic stratification and the emergence of a class-conscious society, man,
particularly in the Western world, distanced him-/her-self from nature and began
using plants and animals to serve his/her needs and pleasures. In the course of
time, this pride of humanity spread across the globe.
However, once Darwin came up with his
theory of evolution, the pride of humanity took a reverse swing as all
organisms have turned out to be of equal value, for ‘survival is the only
criterion of evolutionary success.’ And this, as Julian Huxley observed, became
apparent not because of the exaggeration of the human qualities of animals but
more due to the minimization of the human qualities of men.
This reduced gap between humans and
animals could not, of course, last longer, for science has made firm inroads –
particularly, the extension of scientific analysis to the events all around had
prompted man to re-examine the understanding he has hitherto, including that of
the biological processes.
This increased knowledge enabled man to
look at himself as a unique animal, the uniqueness as reflected in his
exclusive capabilities such as the capacity for conceptual thought—abstraction
and synthesis—and its unique by-products: conversation, organized games,
education, duty, sin, humiliation, vice, penitence, and all these have
cumulatively made him again distinctly different from animals.
To be precise, it is this ability to
reflect—the only animal that not only knows but also knows that it knows— that
has led man believe that he is distinctly different from other living
creatures.
These unique capabilities opened up new
vistas in biosciences. His mastery of the art of culturing cells in the lab has
made the immutable building blocks of individual cells into malleable
resources—into great technologies in themselves.
Man’s ability to produce hybrid cells
has not only gained tremendous economic significance but also challenged his
very fundamental notions of ‘individuality and immortality’.
That aside, his relentless search for
understanding how that primitive bacterium could harness sunlight, almost 3.2
bn years back, to split water molecules into protons, electrons and oxygen—the
very mechanism of photosynthesis that led to the atmospheric oxygen and
ultimately life as we see it today— has at last come to fruition.
Junko Yano et al have presented the
precise structure of a catalyst composed of four manganese atoms and one
calcium atom that drives the water-splitting reaction in green leaves in their
paper in Science of 2006 — Where Water Is Oxidized to
Dioxygen: Structure of the Photosynthetic Mn4Ca Cluster— and
this has generated a new hope of developing clean energy technologies that are
carbon neutral in the very near future.
All this leads us to the inevitable
conclusion: there are several questions that still need to be answered—answered
scientifically. It is here that sagacity points to a phenomenon in which
everything is in motion, as perhaps, man’s search has not yet attained fullness
of it.
And, no wonder, if it remains ever so!
But amidst this flux, the need for ‘leadership’ in our science establishments—a
leadership that “can better cultivate than manufacture scientific temper by
providing the soil and the overall climate and environment in which science can
grow”—emerges as the singular most prerequisite to keep ourselves focused on the
search for ‘truth’.
Now, against this reality, let us question ourselves: Are our universities/institutions
of higher education catering to this urgently felt need? An honest answer is
perhaps: “No”. If that is what the truth is, don’t you think we are losing the
race in the global competition? It is no wonder why none of our institutions of
higher learning finds a place in the oft-released list of the world’s best
universities.
What could be the reason for such an
apathy ruling the roost across the country? One immediate answer that strikes
to mind is: the kind of national fervor that we witnessed among our leaders who
ruled the nation and its institutions immediately after independence is somehow
missing today.
If you don’t believe, check how many
new institutions of the kind of IITs, BARCs, IISs and IIMs were built after
Nehru. And also examine the kind of output coming from traditional universities, such as presidency
cities, and old universities like BHU, AMU, Allahabad, Lucknow, Delhi, etc.,
that were indeed known earlier for turning out scientists with national zeal
and commitment!
This malady is not just confined to
governmental organizations alone. Look at even private
individual’s/industrialists’ contributions to the cause of education in the
country today. What are the new institutions of excellence that have come into
existence after TIFR, BITS (Pilani), BHU, Sri Rams, Pachayappas, Loyolas? That
aside, what is more disturbing is that many Indian corporates are today making huge
donations to universities in the West to establish chairs/new Departments in
their names. What an irony!
The present slide in the country’s educational
standards could have been checkmated to a greater extent had the neo-rich
corporates paid attention to this urgent need. Alas! That is not to be so, for
whatever private participation came forth in the recent past is again for
milking consumers —seekers of education.
Over and above it, we also witness a
kind of creeping irrationalism—such as, relying on God’s men and all sorts of Babas;
regional parochialism; cast-defined behaviorism; ‘ism’-driven violence,
etc.—not only into political institutions but also in scientific institutions
and institutions of higher education. As a result, the kind of scientific
temper that the founding fathers of the nation arduously tried to nurture in
these institutions is slowly fading out today.
The net result is that we are falling
way behind even small nations in the pursuit of fundamental research. Some may,
however, argue that we are progressing well in the field of the IT sector, but
let us not forget that what we are catering to is only the application part; we
are only acting as car mechanics but not as car manufacturers. And there is a
hell lot of difference between these two. As Sam Pitroda once observed, we
haven’t developed IT products for sale in the market.
Hardly 11 institutions from India find
a place in the Nature Index 2020 database— an indicator of research
performance of institutions from various countries in natural sciences in a
year—which lists 500 institutions, with our CSIR at No. 164.
We are far behind the output of China.
True, the Indian Pharmaceutical industry has been identified by global leaders
as capable of mass-producing COVID-19 vaccines. But here again, we are only
mass producers of vaccines developed by other countries, except, of course, the
one developed by Bharat Biotech.
In the context of innovative research on
developing a vaccine for Covid-19, it must be admitted that even Bharat Biotech
is lagging behind Pfizer, Moderna, etc. For they have developed the vaccine on
the novel platforms of mRNA technologies vis-a-vis Bharat Biotech using the
older platform of inactivated virus.
Does all this mean we are lacking
enthusiasm for research and innovation? If so, the probable reason for such a
dispirited approach by our scientific establishments could be a lack of a
vibrant research ecosystem.
The fact that our graduates, who, on
moving to Western universities, become fantastic innovators, reconfirms the
missing link of the right ecosystem in our research institutions. So, the
obvious need is: the right leadership to rejuvenate our institutions, and to create the right ecosystem in which
excellence is spotted and nurtured sans bias. Importantly, stratification of
our system on petty considerations is to be eliminated.
This posits a big question: Who has to
bell the cat?
.
